Herschel Walker and abortion hypocrisy

Welcome to this week's edition of A Thousand Words! Let's turn to some news from our own state. With just over a month until Election Day, the midterms are getting interesting. This week, there has been a new development in the Georgia Senate race that the AJC called a "one-two punch" to the Herschel Walker campaign; the Daily Beast is reporting that a woman told them that in 2009 Walker paid for her to get an abortion after he got her pregnant. This story is so significant because of Walker's strongly anti-abortion campaign stance; he has taken an even more extreme stance than many of his Republican colleagues, saying that there should be no exceptions to abortion bans for rape, incest or when the life of the mother is at risk.

Let's take a look at how some different outlets have covered this story - and as usual, look at the photos that they chose!

First off, let's look at the original article from the Daily Beast, which is being run as an exclusive. It's called "'Pro-Life' Herschel Walker Paid for Girlfriend's Abortion", and was written by Roger Sollenberger. It is headed by this image:

This is quite a striking image; it's a photo of Walker digitally edited into photo art. Now, as for its relevance to this particular article, I am not particularly sure. This picture doesn't seem, to me at least, to strongly portray Walker in any particular way, which is somewhat surprising considering that the article itself is quite damning of him. And why the color orange? One observation I do have, though, is that this kind of photo art and graphic design is quite common for the Daily Beast. They are a somewhat "tabloid-y" news outlet, and while this design is quite simple, a lot of their articles feature graphics that are arguably a little tacky.

How about local coverage of this Georgia race? Greg Bluestein from the Atlanta Journal Constitution wrote an article called "Stunning developments dog Herschel Walker's campaign at pivotal time." It is accompanied by this photo:

The article mainly focuses on how potentially damaging this news could be for the Walker campaign, then turns to Walker's denial of the claims and his conservative son's public condemnation of his hypocrisy. I think that this photo fits with the tone of the article; it is a fairly neutral portrayal of Walker, but he also looks quite serious in it. Also, I personally feel like there is something quite ominous about the larger than life campaign poster of his own face looming in the background; but maybe I am just projecting! What do you think?

Finally, let's take a look at a conservative perspective on this story. Written by Paul Steinhauser and published in Fox News, this article is entitled "Georgia GOP Senate candidate Herschel Walker denies bombshell report that he paid for a girlfriend's abortion." As the title suggests, this piece centers around Walker's denial of these claims. The first photo within the article is this one:

This is a photo of Walker at a meeting with Black business leaders, and in it he looks friendly and smiling. This more positive portrayal of the Republican candidate is not very surprising from conservative Fox News. On the other hand, the only other photo in the article is one of Senator Warnock in which he looks such as friendly.

What do you all think about these photos, as well as this story itself. How much do you think it will affect the Senate race? Will most Republican voters believe Walker's denial? Might this case of hypocrisy put them off from voting for him? Or do you think they may overlook it in favor of his other conservative policies?

Comments

  1. I found the last one most striking! That image has no relevance to the headline, but as you said, it is pretty on theme of Fox News to portray republican candidates in a positive light, even when they are facing negative accusations. This just seems like an overly obvious attempt to distract from the issue, which probably isn't even necessary. The same way that his supporters believe he never abused his wife, I doubt they will believe this story, even though it is not far-fetched in the slightest. Powerful men are always seen doing things like this, and they usually always get away with it.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment