The "Red Wave" that was not

Hi there, welcome back to A Thousand Words. On this blog I tend to look at stories that have a particular individual as the subject, so I thought I would change it up a bit and look at something broader that might offer a greater variety of photo choices. Last week were the midterm elections, and the Democrats did surprisingly well at the polls. For months, pollsters, political scientists and journalists have been predicting a "Red Wave". There were good reasons to believe that this would be the case, including historical patterns of midterm elections, troubles with the economy under the current administration and Biden's low approval ratings. But while the Republicans are likely to take the House when all the votes are finished being counted, the Democrats have maintained control of the Senate and overall did much better than expected. Ever since the election, the media has been full of articles analyzing why this was the case. Let's take a look at some of those articles and see what images were chosen to represent this coverage.

First off, let's look at an opinion piece by Sohrab Ahmari, published in the New York Times. It is called "Why the Red Wave Didn't Materialize", and features this image:

I think this is a great example of careful image choice, and really showcases some of the topics I have been trying to highlight on this blog. On the surface level, this is a picture of someone getting ready to vote. But there are some important details about this particular voter. First off, they have chosen an image of a Black voter, a demographic that is often credited with the extent of Democratic success in 2020 and again this year. Furthermore, it seems very patriotic to fill out one's ballot request form with an American flag pen. I am just speculating, but what this image says to me is that the liberal-leaning New York Times finds the lack of a red wave a win for American patriotism and democracy.

Next, an article from New York Magazine's Intelligencer. In the piece, entitled "Why Tom Bonier Knew There Would Be No Red Wave", Nia Prater interviews Democratic strategist Tom Bonier. The interview is headed by this photo:

In the interview, Bonier talks about the importance of the Dobbs decision in giving Democrats an advantage. This image, which is of an abortion rights protester's hand, reflects that. The caption for the image informs the reader that "the green bandana symbolizes the pro-abortion-rights movement," but importantly, the liberal target audience for this article will likely recognize this symbol right away, drawing them into the article.

Today, Insider published an article entitled "Mitch McConnell says he 'never predicted a red wave' and that independent and moderate Republican voters were 'frightened' by GOP." Written by Bryan Metzger, the article is accompanied by the following picture:

The topic of the article in interesting in itself, as it's one example of numerous Republicans working to distance themselves from the far right wing of the party that many commenters have blamed for the GOP's lack of success (despite the fact that many of these Republican figures have aligned themselves with the "Trump wing" in the past.) Given that he is the subject of the article, it makes sense that a photo of Sen. McConnell was chosen. He looks somewhat concerned in the picture, but to be honest I find his expression hard to read. McConnell is notorious for odd and arguably off-putting facial expressions; anyone who has watched the "Weekend Update" segment of Saturday Night Live knows that pictures of his face are often used as the subject of jokes.

Finally, let's look at an international perspective from the BBC. They published an article called "US midterms: Why a Republican 'wave' never happened," which was written by Bernd Debusmann Jr and Natalie Sherman, and features this photo:
The choice to feature a picture of a Trump campaign bus in an article about the midterms, despite the fact that he was not a candidate in these elections, has several potential implications. For one thing, the signatures on the bus show that he still has significant support among Republican voters. It also alludes to the influence that he had over these midterms, something that the article brings up; some commentators have blamed Republicans' continued association with the former president for their disappointing results. Perhaps most importantly, Trump is a very recognizable figure to the British audience this article is aimed at, who might not be terribly familiar with other American political figures who were actually up for election this year.

Unless I have miscalculated, I believe that this is my last post on this blog! I would love to hear your thoughts on the things I have covered this semester. How important do you think image choice is to political journalism? What has been your favorite example of how messages can be conveyed through visuals? Are there any examples you wish I had covered here?

Thank you for reading!!

Comments

  1. Tigerlily,
    I believe I would have interpreted the four photos in this blog as you have. A possibility for the Mitch McConnel photo is that he could be saying somewhat nonchalantly “here we are, I never predicted a red wave, no big deal,” as if shrugging it off. He frequently gives me the impression that he is somewhat passive. I have not seen him demonstrate power or assertiveness.

    You have done a wonderful job in your blogs of tying in photos to enhance the written news stories and interpreting their connection. Pictures just add so much nuance and power to the message. Some of the photos overtly embellish the narrative, while some of them create an almost subliminal element. I especially enjoyed your blog of protest photos which invoked an emotional reaction.

    ReplyDelete
  2. While reading your blog post your interpretation of the pictures is kind of how I interpreted them. The image that stood out to me the most was the “Why the Red Wave Didn’t Materialize”, this picture for great for representation in the African-American community. Young adults can see someone like them voting and this could encourage them to also go vote. I personally believe representation matters a lot in African-American community. In every picture, they use the person in the picture to show representation or even make a bigger statement. In media pitches matter for people that are visual learners, and it also helps people understand exactly what someone could be talking about.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I must say, I really like the style of this blog. The idea of using pictures as the article is great. I agree with your interpretation of the picture of Trump on the bus. Whether we like it or not, he is here to stay and the impact he had on American politics cannot be denied. I agree that the republicans are losing a lot of their voter base by not straying far enough away from Trump.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment