Giorgia Meloni - Fascist or Feminist?

Hello and welcome to this week's post on A Thousand Words. Today I will be looking at coverage of Giorgia Meloni winning the vote to become Italy's next Prime Minister.

Meloni will be Italy's first female Prime Minister. She is also a far-right member of the Brothers of Italy Party - the party of Benito Mussolini. Coverage of her win yesterday appears to be split by the choice of which of these factors to focus on. Let's look at some of these articles, and the images that go along with them.

The first article I will look is from The Guardian. It was written by Van Badham and is strikingly entitled "The election of fascist-adjacent Giorgia Meloni is a public reminder that women can be just as awful as men." The article criticizes coverage that focuses on Meloni as the first female Prime Minister and frames her as a traditional conservative rather than a far-right extremist. It is headed by this image:

Interesting, many of the articles I found used images in which Meloni appears to be laughing or grinning. Perhaps this is a regular personality feature for her, or maybe it is just because a lot of these photos were taken from when she was celebrating her win. Either way, what I found very interesting was that articles both in defense of Meloni and those criticizing her used these laughing pictures. Depending on the context, these images can come across very differently. A picture of a politician laughing or smiling can humanize them and make the audience feel more sympathetic towards them; it can be a pleasant change from how serious politics seems most of the time. However, when attached to someone who has connections to fascism, these images could make them seem cruel; they could perhaps make the audience feel as though the subject is a villain, and imagine a cartoonishly evil laugh to accompany the photo. What do you think is the case here? What do these images make you feel?

The next article is called "White House anxiously watches Meloni's rise to power." It was written by Jonathan Lemire and published in Politico. It looks at Meloni's win from the perspective of American foreign policy, and discusses concerns that it could cause instability in G7 and NATO. The picture that accompanies it is this one:

This is another photo of Meloni celebrating her victory. She is holding a sign that translates to "Thank you Italy." Again, the question is, how does this image reflect how the audience is meant to feel about Meloni? How intentional was this choice of image for this particular publication?

The third piece is from The Atlantic; it's written by Yascha Mounk and entitled "Italians Didn't Exactly Vote for Fascism." It does not exactly defend Meloni from the fascist accusations, but rather questions her political power and longevity. It is accompanied by this photo:

Personally, I think that this is the image in which Meloni looks most like a villain; the angle, her expression and the black background all add to this portrayal. This is interesting because this article is arguing that she is not really as much of a threat as she has been portrayed to be. What does fit, though, is that this is a more striking piece of photography than the other photos we have looked at so far; I have noted in a previous post that many of these publications chose more interesting images for their opinion pieces than is typical for news reporting.

Finally, let's look at a different article from The Atlantic which takes a different angle. Written by Ruth Ben-Ghiat, the title contrasts that of the previous piece: "The Return of Fascism in Italy." The article compares Meloni to France's Le Pen, arguing that both women have leant into their non-threatening femininity to soften their extremism. It argues that Meloni is different, however, because she has never fully denounced her party's fascist attachments. Here is its accompanying photo:

This is the only one of the four images here in which Meloni looks serious. The upwards angle is a classic photography technique to portray power. This seems appropriate for this article, which is arguing that Meloni is, in fact, a fascist threat.

What do you all think about these images? If you saw the pictures of Meloni laughing without the context of the articles they accompany, what would your impression of her be? What about the last image in which she looks more serious?

Comments